MORE, MORE, MORE

Warning. This review contains spoilers for the Enemy Within campaign.

It may have taken more than one bite of the cherry, but Cubicle 7 has now released the full text of the Enemy in Shadows Companion, making several additions and changes to the version it initially made available. It seems a good time, therefore, to share my thoughts on the book.

The Enemy in Shadows Companion is the first of five planned companion volumes to accompany C7’s reissue of the Enemy Within campaign for WFRP4. It comprises a miscellany of supplementary material for use with the first adventure in the series, Enemy in Shadows. This includes a selection of additional NPCs, encounters and adventures, alongside some thematic material relating to the Empire, road travel and Chaos.

(For more information about the new version of The Enemy Within, see this background post and my review of Enemy in Shadows.)

PRESENTATION

The Enemy in Shadows Companion is 127 pages long. Its general presentation matches that of other WFRP4 products. Maps are good, showing building plans and vertical elevations. There is a sprinkling of handouts, but they are small and only presented in the text columns. Art is somewhat less impressive than in other products in the range. It is largely black and white; there are few colour images, and at least one of them is a duplicate from another book.

Layout follows the same design as other WFRP4 books. Unfortunately, the heavy use of text boxes creates a problem with NPC descriptions. Many of the text boxes are dislocated and do not sit alongside the description of the NPC to which they relate. It makes the arrangement a little unclear and untidy. The problem is exacerbated by the fact that the headings of some of the text boxes provide few clues as which NPC they relate to.

ANCIENT HISTORY

The opening chapters are of purely historical interest. They contain reminiscences from two of the campaign’s original authors, Phil Gallagher and Graeme Davis, and an account of the origins of names and plot ideas in Enemy in Shadows.

The information is brief (five pages in total) and, apart from notes on a few names, has appeared in other places before, so there are no major revelations. But it is a good summary, and it is always pleasant to hear the history in the authors’ own words.

THE LIE OF THE LAND

The first chapter of content relevant to play is a ten-page guide to the Empire. This has little to say about everyday life in the Empire and focuses primarily on politics and government. It describes the Provinces and Prime Estates; the Emperor, Council of State, Elector Counts, Electors and Plenipotentiaries; and other aspects such as guilds, taxation, law and social classes. The content is not purely background information: scattered throughout the text are also several adventure ideas.

The material mostly derives from the original Enemy Within (1986) and its various reprints. Interestingly this means that the political situation in the Empire reflects that of the first edition of WFRP, not the somewhat different circumstances of subsequent editions. Thus Yorri XV is Grand Theogonist; Sudenland is a Province; Middenheim and Middenland are separately governed territories; Crown Prince Wolfgang Holswig-Abenauer is heir to the Emperor. There are some concessions to later versions of the background, though. For example, the Emperor has a son, Luitpold, but he has recently been disinherited and banished for reasons left mysterious.

Comments made elsewhere by the designers suggest that this political situation will not persist. It seems likely that during the course of the Enemy Within campaign, the Empire will be reshaped by political crisis (just as it was in the original finale, Empire in Flames, and the unofficial alternative, The Empire at War), allowing the designers to accommodate the different politics of later editions alongside those of the first edition.

Despite its focus on the upper echelons of Imperial life, the information in this section is likely to be invaluable to GMs of the campaign. Imperial political ructions are an important element of the original Enemy Within, especially in its later stages, and this is likely also to be the case for the new version. Yet the political context of the Empire is neglected in the WFRP4 rulebook, because of its narrow focus on the Reikland.

The material in the Enemy in Shadows Companion goes some way to correct that omission. However, the information perhaps more naturally belongs in the core rulebook. That the rulebook contains detailed descriptions of towns without some of the basics of the political backdrop strikes me as putting the cart before the horse. A more successful approach might have been to provide a high-level overview of the Empire in the rulebook and greater regional detail in supplements.

Another unfortunate effect of this arrangement is that the Empire is presented piecemeal. It seems likely that GMs who want a full picture of the Empire will have to acquire and trawl through several different volumes to get it, rather than have it collated in a single volume like Sigmar’s Heirs for WFRP2.

Delberz Delbren

KEEPING THE SHOW ON THE ROAD

The next topic covered in the Companion is life on the Empire’s roads. 24 pages are dedicated to this topic across four chapters. They contain a combination of background material and game mechanics: a short account of roads and major coaching houses; discussion of roadwardens and toll-keepers; rules for driving and riding; and a system for dealing with road journeys abstractly.

The background information is solid, but brief, amounting to barely four pages in total. Moreover, some parts, such as the road descriptions, seem to me to be sufficiently obvious as to be superfluous.

More useful is the material on mounts and vehicles. There are profiles for eight types of draught animal and mount. Rules are provided for calculating travelling speeds, handling mounted and vehicular combat and introducing random mishaps. They provide a very good framework for running cinematic action sequences like coach chases. However, they seem to me less effective at dealing with the more prosaic issue of travelling from A to B. It is not clear, for example, how the rules can be used to calculate a daily travelling speed by coach. This part of the rules is in need of at least some clarification and possibly even a rewrite. The inclusion of summary tables of average daily travelling distances would also be a valuable improvement.

The heart of the travelling rules, though, is a set of mechanics for handling journeys in an abstract manner, which is modelled on the downtime rules in the WFRP4 rulebook. Different weather conditions and their effects are covered, including elements such as illness from exposure. There are three tables of encounters (positive, neutral and negative). There are also a range of travel endeavours, similar to those in downtime: woodcraft, forage, gather information, keep watch, map the route, practise a skill, recuperate and make camp.

I had mixed opinions of the WFRP4 downtime system, but the system presented here is better. The rules for weather, encounters and endeavours are very good additions. I do, though, have a niggle about the system of Travel Stages. GMs are required to divide journeys into a subjective number of stages and then adjust that number for movement rates and skills. Given that the initial number of stages is entirely arbitrary, it seems to me pointless then to apply mechanical adjustments to it. This is easily amended, however.

CENTRAL CASTING

The Enemy in Shadows Companion contains a substantial collection of standalone NPCs. Across two chapters and 24 pages there are detailed descriptions of 22 of them: artisan, bawd, beggar, bounty hunter, brigand, bunko artist, charlatan, entertainer, highwayman, merchant, noble, outlaw, pedlar, racketeer, road warden, servant, stevedore, thief and toll keeper. They include characteristic allusions to historical and fictional characters, such as a bunko artist called Heinrich “the Grouch” Marken (Groucho Marx) and a pedlar called Delberz Trötte (Del Boy Trotter).

The descriptions include WFRP4 profiles, black-and-white illustrations, adventure ideas and guidance on using the NPCs in Enemy in Shadows. They are an excellent resource, useful not just in Enemy in Shadows, but in almost any scenario.

Roadwardens

THE LOST AND THE DAMNED

Two chapters, extending to 26 pages in total, provide more information on the threat of Chaos. They contain a short account of mutant society; three tables for randomly generating mutations; a description of the Purple Hand cult; rules for Chaos sorcerers, including new talents, a Cult Magus career and spell lores of Chaos and Tzeentch; and details of some lesser demons (Chaos furies and pink and blue horrors).

The information is well put together and useful. The description of mutant society is pleasingly nuanced. Mutants are presented as more than just crazed cannon fodder. The mutation tables cover three types of mutation (physical mutations, bestial heads and mental mutations), and include custom rolls for each Chaos power.

Mutation Table

Extract from a mutation table

The details on Chaos sorcerers, magic and demons are excellent and likely to be very valuable for GMs, given the central role of Chaos in the Enemy Within campaign.

The only disappointing part is the description of the Purple Hand. While it suffices for the needs of the adventure, it does not provide a lot of detail. It largely repeats information that was provided in Warhammer City (1987, reprinted as Middenheim: City of Chaos, 1998). It says nothing of the cult’s plans as they affect the campaign, and does not equip the GM well to develop its storyline.

OLD CHESTNUTS

The final three chapters of the Enemy in Shadows Companion comprise reprints of short scenarios from WFRP1. Together they take up another 29 pages of the total count.

The first reprint, ‘On the Road’, by Graeme Davis, has a long history. It dates back to the very beginning of WFRP, and was the first article published in White Dwarf specifically for the game, back in WD85 (January 1987). It describes a pair of brief encounters, one with a shapeshifter and another with a ghost. It is a good fit with Enemy in Shadows. Thematically it ties in with the road trip at the beginning of the adventure, and stylistically it is similar, as it was written by one of the same authors at same time as the original adventures.

Graeme Davis has said ‘On the Road’ was “based on recycled ideas and written in a hurry to fill a need for magazine fodder, at a time when WFRP still didn’t really know what it was going to be when it grew up”. But that seems to me an unduly harsh self assessment. The encounters are short and simple, but atmospheric. They are good examples of doing a lot with a little. With some imagination and work they could easily be developed into more substantial adventures, as in The Restless Dead (1989), where Carl Sargent used them as the hook for a whole campaign.

The second reprinted article is ‘The Affair of the Hidden Jewel’, by Lewis Page, which first appeared in WD101 (May 1988), and was reprinted in The Restless Dead (1989) and Apocrypha 2: Chart of Darkness (2000). It strikes a different tone from WFRP‘s characteristic grit and filth. Subtitled “A Melodrama with a Thick Plot”, it is a tongue-in-cheek tale of swashbuckling derring-do, featuring a band of outlaws, a castle and an evil count. It embraces stereotypes and clichés with gusto, though I note with disappointment that, unlike the original adventure, PCs are not rewarded with experience points for “Appropriately Corny Lines”.

It is a less obvious scenario to include in the Companion. It is certainly fun, and provides a nice counterpoint to the darker tone of Enemy in Shadows, but it is not a classic. Moreover, it contains elements that may be duplicated in the next part of the campaign, Death on the Reik: a band of outlaws, a castle and a secret passage. These are hackneyed enough when run once, but repeating them in quick succession seems likely to elicit groans from players.

The final recycled scenario is ‘The Pandemonium Carnival’, by Mike Brunton, from Apocrypha 2: Charts of Darkness (2000). This describes in detail a travelling freak show, along with several short adventure ideas (four from the original printing, plus a new addition).

The material fits in neatly with the Schaffenfest in Enemy in Shadows, but repeats elements of the existing freak show, Doktor Malthusius’ Zoocopoeia. The Pandemonium Carnival is probably best seen as an alternative to or expansion of the Zoocopeia.

Aside from the inclusion of WFRP4 statistics, all three reprinted adventures are substantially the same as in their first appearances. This means they preserve features that are no longer consistent with the Warhammer world, such as werecats and captive beastmen. Notes are provided on reconciling these elements with the current background.

FAMILIAR FACES

Cubicle 7 has recently (and belatedly) added six pregenerated PCs to the PDF version of the Enemy in Shadows Companion. They are the same six as appeared thirty-three years ago in the original campaign: Harbull Furfoot, a halfling Herb Gatherer; Werner Murrmann, a human Apprentice Artisan (no longer nicknamed “Pick-Axe”); Wanda Weltschmertz (sic), a human Wizard’s Apprentice; Johann “Rowlocks” Dassbütt, a human Boat-Hand; Malmir Giluviel, an elf Busker; and Kirsten Krank, a human Prowler.

Each has a full two-page character sheet. The first page contains statistics and is laid out in a similar fashion to C7’s downloadable WFRP4 character sheet, but with some compression. The second page contains a written description of the character, including background, personality and appearance, along with a colour illustration.

The sheets are mostly usable as they are printed. One or two minor details are missing, such as age and height. Some parts of the sheets do not allow enough space for future changes, such as Wanda Weltschmertz’s spell list. But it seems reasonable to assume the statistics will at some point be transferred to a blank character sheet with room for these emendations. Then the first page can be discarded and the second page retained.

The written character notes are hardly changed from the original versions, save in one respect. The new descriptions include a selection of optional character secrets. For example, Kirsten Krank is the illegitimate daughter of a noble; Johann Dassbütt wants revenge on her over an unpaid ferry fare; he is wanted for murder in Delberz; etc. PCs receive D10 pennies for each secret they have. They are interesting twists, but require careful management by the GM, especially as they can create intra-party conflict. In my opinion, their use should very much be at the GM’s discretion.

The original version of the Enemy Within campaign was to some extent written around these characters, so they fit well with Enemy in Shadows and probably with the remainder of the campaign. However, since the characters have been relegated to the companion volume, the specific notes to the GM on using them in the adventures have been lost. It is a minor loss, as the notes are generally obvious.

The Old Gang

The New Gang

The old gang and the new

OVERALL

The Enemy in Shadows Companion is excellent. There is a good variety of well written and useful material. Very little of it is specific to Enemy in Shadows. Instead the Companion is primarily a collection of standalone material, with thematic links to the main adventure and notes on how it might be included in the campaign. The result is that it gives GMs of Enemy in Shadows a great number of options for expanding the adventure, but the additions are only loosely linked to the main adventure. However, this also means that the Companion‘s usefulness is not restricted to that adventure; almost all of its content is of value to GMs of other scenarios.

Ironically those parts of the content that do relate directly to Enemy in Shadows (such as a map of The Berebeli and the background to Imperial politics) seem to me too important to have been relegated to the companion volume. They should perhaps have been included in the main adventure. Nonetheless, it seems likely that most GMs of the adventure will also buy the Companion, so I suspect there will be few complaints.

The usual caveat about reprints applies; around a third of the book is reheated first edition fare. The handling of the older content is noteworthy. At Gen Con 2018 Graeme Davis discussed WFRP4 trying to “be all things to all people”. That certainly seems to be the approach in the Enemy in Shadows Companion. It seeks to accommodate multiple versions of the Warhammer world. This “broad church” attitude is very welcome, and bodes well for future books.

For my other WFRP4 reviews, see this link.

The review copy of the Enemy in Shadows Companion was purchased at my own expense. I have received no inducements in connection with this review.

Title art by JG O’Donaghue. Internal art by JG O’ Donaghue, Tony Ackland et al. Used without permission. No challenge intended to the rights holders.

19 thoughts on “MORE, MORE, MORE

  1. The weather rules sound interesting. My PC’s are due to make a mountain trip through winter weather and snow shortly and I was wondering how to handle things like exposure.

    Like

  2. Not too far off my views.

    I think, and I don’t want this to sound harsh as I think it’s a good supplement, is this the cutting room floor material after hitting the page count with Enemy in Shadows. There is a lot of material that could go into the Companion but simultaneously restricted by the page count.

    I think the weakest point is the chapter on The Purple Hand. Other sections generally achieve what they set to, and most are good. The info on The Purple Hand is just too vague, it reads more as an abstract Tzeentchian cult. It will be intersting to see if we get anything in depth on The Red Crown and if so how the two contrast at all.

    Have you got the starter set yet? There is a little bit more in the weeds info the Urbersreik background. It looks a little more institutions/trades for the working classes (urban, at least).

    Liked by 1 person

      1. On the whole, yes.

        There are quite a few pieces to the set and they each have varying levels of usefulness, but I imagine to someone very new to WFRP, it’s generally very good.

        The D100 (a units and a tens) is nice, the tokens could come in useful, but neither are things that can’t be acquired or provided elsewhere.

        The two printed pull out maps are decent, but I’d say the map of the Duchy is superior. The GM screen is mis-selling as it’s just the inside of the box with the new map of the Reikland on it. The pullout reference sheets are useful and will be handy even after the proper GM screen is released.

        The main contents are the adventure and source material. The adventure is okay but a little rail-roady. Given it’s the starting point there is some defence to this (not unlike Mistaken Identity) but it continues to compel the characters into a role: indentured watchmen. The adventure plays out as a mix of procedural detective work with some nice keep-the-peace scenarios thrown.

        The pullout character sheets with the pregens are quite nice and foreshadow the background secrets we see with the Johan and Wanda et al in the new Companion (they got 6D10 pennies per secret).

        The best part is the source book though, it’s quite detailed on Ubersreik. It has a history/timeline and a short section discussing the current politics. After that, there is a good 40 pages on the town that covers the various guilds, markets, taverns, sewers etc. with a few NPCs thrown in. There is the obligitory section on cults and a few pages for the surrounding rural areas.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Good review. I find this a more useful volume than Enemy in Shadows itself and probably would even if I hadn’t already been long past Bogenhafen in my campaign run when they appeared. 🙂

    Personally I’m not wild about the by-now certain (not least since Andy Law has confirmed it) intent to use the new TEW to harmonize the contradictory versions of the setting, but I can definitely see the point to doing so. On the other hand, the willingness of the Companion to openly discuss some of these contradictions and retcons, as in the notes on “On the Road”, is appealing.

    I agree the writeup on the Purple Hand was a disappointment. It’s kind of odd how they’re still, after over 30 years, a strange hole at the centre of the TEW campaign and the Chaos cults in general – while there have been some writeups on organisation and so on we’ve still never had any proper insight into their actual motivations. Why does someone become a Purple Hand cultist? What’s in it for them? It doesn’t help that, even though ostensibly the main plot of Power Behind the Throne is masterminded by the leader of the PH, the cult as such plays basically no role at all in the adventure. I’m curious whether this will be adressed in the new PBtT.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m not sure I’d describe the approach to background inconsistencies so far as “harmonising”. I don’t think it tries so much to eliminate inconsistencies as to embrace them. If you want werecats or an enfeebled Emperor, the background can accommodate them. Since it is unlikely in my view that GW would reverse decades of changes to the Warhammer world since WFRP’s first edition, it seems to me the best case grognards like me could realistically expect.

      I agree about the Purple Hand and Chaos cults in general. There is certainly insufficient explanation of cultists’ motivations. Where are the charismatic leaders? What do cultists expect to get from their membership? What recruitment techniques do cults employ? Etc.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I should probably have been more specific. I referred to “harmonising” in the sense that the new TEW seems to aim at keeping as much as possible from the earlier editions, even when the elements would seem to contradict each other (such as the nature of Karl-Franz, the list of provinces, or whether the Empire is complacently unthreatened or under constant invasion) – and rather making a game out of coming up with ways that “both versions are true”, as Graeme Davis put it in an early interview about what Karl-Franz would be like in the new version.

        Andy Law seemed to confirm this in a thread in the WFRP 4E Facebook group (https://www.facebook.com/groups/1718549725113205/permalink/2199315650369941/):

        “This [using the new TEW to make apparently-contradictory background elements “both true”] was my choice and I pitched it to GW. At the time, they were delighted with the direction I chose, and enthusiastically engaged with it. In short, the Empire of the Enemy Within and the Empire of Warhammer 4-8 are not incompatible. Instead, they simply show the Empire at two different points in its history. As I mentioned at Warhammerfest, the Enemy Within is the story of how one becomes the other, amongst many other things.”

        And as you say, this is probably the best we could expect. As I’ve pointed out before I’m quite aware I’m not the core target audience for the new TEW. 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Another update to the PDF is available. Looks like some good work has been done with layout from skimming through with better use of space. The Berebeli art is not numbered, so it may be moved to the inside cover.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I find the difference between the ‘old gang’ and ‘new gang’ illustrations interesting. I wonder if perhaps they are, or will be, illustrative of the difference between the first edition and the fourth edition. The new gang are characterful, in the action, colourful. The old gang have character but are seemingly ordinary, prepared (they have backpacks and sacks) for an adventure as best they could be but not necessarily ready for one, mundane. It’s not that i dislike the new gang, or at least i think there are things to like about them, but i think they have lost something in translation. To my eye the new gang are, dare i say, DnD.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. I can’t disagree that there is a whiff of WWE about the new version, though i did briefly think that i would. The phrase ‘heroic scale’ also comes to mind.

        Incidentally, i think that ‘WWE whiffing’ is probably a good description of some WWE performances, at least from what little i’ve seen of it and heard about it.

        Like

      1. I didn’t know that those miniatures even existed, or at least i’ve long forgotten them.

        Like

      2. I had a few of those miniatures but i hadn’t known they were for The Enemy Within. I bought quite a few of them second hand and they were all for Advanced Heroquest, for which a few of them at least were repurposed.

        Like

      3. Thanks Gideon, I had one pullout showing just the gang from SoB I think. I don’t believe I’d seen the full DotR set before advert.
        I might ask my cousin who got me into the stuff in the early nineties; he had quite a few similar looking miniatures to those along with owning the DotR box set. He might have had that set. I’ll see if he’s still got them.
        Also, I think boots and a cape are practical wear for traipsing around the Reikland.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.